Skip to content

The four Sunni schools in Islamic inheritance

Most estates come out the same in all four schools. Here is what each school does differently, and every family in the test suite where the results differ.

The calculator runs every estate through the same engine with the school as an input. Each section lists the positions the engine applies for that school; the comparison tables at the end are computed when the page loads.

Ḥanafī

Founding jurist
Abū Ḥanīfa al-Nuʿmān (d. 150 AH / 767 CE)
Mainly followed in
Turkey, the Balkans, Central Asia and South Asia

What the calculator applies

  • The grandfather (jadd) stands in for the father and excludes all brothers and sisters.
  • No Mushtaraka: in that same family the full brothers are residuaries (ʿaṣaba) and get nothing once the fixed shares take the whole estate.
  • Radd (return): a surplus with no residuary heir goes back to the fixed-share heirs, never to a spouse who shares with them.
  • A spouse who is the only heir takes the whole estate: the later Ḥanafī fatwa returns the surplus to them (Ibn ʿĀbidīn, Radd al-Muḥtār).
  • Extended family (dhawū al-arḥām) inherit by closeness of kinship (ahl al-qarāba), class by class, a male taking twice a female.

Mālikī

Founding jurist
Mālik ibn Anas (d. 179 AH / 795 CE)
Mainly followed in
North and West Africa

What the calculator applies

  • The grandfather (jadd) inherits alongside full and paternal siblings by Zayd ibn Thābit's method — sharing (muqāsama), a third or a sixth, whichever is best for him — including al-muʿādda and al-Akdariyya.
  • al-Mushtaraka: when a husband, a mother or grandmother, two or more maternal siblings and full brothers meet, the full brothers share the maternal siblings' third instead of going without.
  • Radd (return) as the school's later scholars apply it — the earlier position sends the surplus to the bayt al-māl (public treasury) — spouses excluded. The result carries a note saying so.
  • A spouse who is the only heir takes their fixed share and the school sends the rest to the bayt al-māl (public treasury), so the calculator marks the case for a scholar's review.
  • Extended family (dhawū al-arḥām) inherit by substitution (ahl al-tanzīl), following the later scholars: each takes the share of the heir they connect through, a male taking twice a female. Combinations the texts leave open are marked for review.

Shāfiʿī

Founding jurist
Muḥammad ibn Idrīs al-Shāfiʿī (d. 204 AH / 820 CE)
Mainly followed in
Egypt, East Africa, Yemen and Southeast Asia

What the calculator applies

  • The grandfather (jadd) inherits alongside full and paternal siblings by Zayd ibn Thābit's method — sharing (muqāsama), a third or a sixth, whichever is best for him — including al-muʿādda and al-Akdariyya.
  • al-Mushtaraka: when a husband, a mother or grandmother, two or more maternal siblings and full brothers meet, the full brothers share the maternal siblings' third instead of going without.
  • Radd (return) as the school's later scholars apply it — the earlier position sends the surplus to the bayt al-māl (public treasury) — spouses excluded. The result carries a note saying so.
  • A spouse who is the only heir takes their fixed share and the school sends the rest to the bayt al-māl (public treasury), so the calculator marks the case for a scholar's review.
  • Extended family (dhawū al-arḥām) inherit by substitution (ahl al-tanzīl), following the later scholars: each takes the share of the heir they connect through, a male taking twice a female. Combinations the texts leave open are marked for review.

Ḥanbalī

Founding jurist
Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal (d. 241 AH / 855 CE)
Mainly followed in
Saudi Arabia and Qatar

What the calculator applies

  • The grandfather (jadd) inherits alongside full and paternal siblings by Zayd ibn Thābit's method — sharing (muqāsama), a third or a sixth, whichever is best for him — including al-muʿādda and al-Akdariyya.
  • No Mushtaraka: in that same family the full brothers are residuaries (ʿaṣaba) and get nothing once the fixed shares take the whole estate.
  • Radd (return): a surplus with no residuary heir goes back to the fixed-share heirs, never to a spouse who shares with them.
  • A spouse who is the only heir takes their fixed share and the school sends the rest to the bayt al-māl (public treasury), so the calculator marks the case for a scholar's review.
  • Extended family (dhawū al-arḥām) inherit by substitution (ahl al-tanzīl): each takes the share of the heir they connect through, males and females equally.

Where the schools give different shares

60 families in the calculator's test suite come out differently in at least one school. Each table below is computed by the engine as this page loads.

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/21/21/2
Full brother excluded1/21/21/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/31/31/3
Full brother × 2excluded2/32/32/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/31/31/3
Full brother × 3excluded2/32/32/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 12/32/32/3
Full sister excluded1/31/31/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 5/65/185/185/18
Full brother × 2excluded5/95/95/9
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Mother, Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/31/31/3
Mother 1/32/92/92/9
Father's father 1/68/278/278/27
Full sister excluded4/274/274/27
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/41/41/4
Full brother excluded1/41/41/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/31/31/3
Full sister excluded1/61/61/6
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter × 22/32/32/32/3
Father's father 1/31/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/61/61/6
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Paternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Son's daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/41/41/4
Paternal brother excluded1/41/41/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister, Paternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 12/52/52/5
Full sister excluded1/21/21/2
Paternal brother excluded1/101/101/10
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister, Paternal sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 12/52/52/5
Full sister excluded1/21/21/2
Paternal sister × 2excluded1/101/101/10
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister, Paternal brother, Paternal sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 5/65/185/185/18
Full sister excluded1/21/21/2
Paternal brother excluded1/271/271/27
Paternal sister excluded1/541/541/54
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister, Paternal brother, Paternal sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 5/65/185/185/18
Full sister excluded1/21/21/2
Paternal brother × 2excluded2/452/452/45
Paternal sister excluded1/901/901/90
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/31/31/3
Full brother excluded2/32/32/3
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/31/31/3
Full sister × 2excluded2/32/32/3
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/41/41/4
Full sister excluded1/41/41/4
Paternal sister excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/51/51/5
Full sister excluded3/103/103/10
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Mother, Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/31/31/3
Mother 1/32/92/92/9
Father's father 1/68/278/278/27
Father's mother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Full sister excluded4/274/274/27
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Mother, Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/31/31/3
Mother 1/32/92/92/9
Father's father 1/68/278/278/27
Mother's mother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Full sister excluded4/274/274/27
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 1/31/61/61/6
Full sister excluded1/61/61/6
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother × 2excluded1/61/6excluded
Maternal sister × 21/31/61/61/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Full sister, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/121/12excluded
Full sister excluded1/121/12excluded
Maternal brother × 21/31/61/61/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 5/65/185/185/18
Father's mother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Full brother × 2excluded5/95/95/9
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Mother's mother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 5/65/125/125/12
Full brother excluded5/125/125/12
Maternal brother × 2excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Wife

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Wife 1needs a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's review
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1needs a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's review
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Great-granddaughter 1/21/21/21/2
Father's father 1/21/41/41/4
Full brother excluded1/41/41/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Great-granddaughter 1/61/61/61/6
Father's father 1/31/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/61/61/6
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter 1/21/21/21/2
Son's daughter 1/61/61/61/6
Great-granddaughter excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Father's father 1/31/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/61/61/6
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/21/21/2
Full brother excluded1/21/21/2
Full nephew excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full sister, Paternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 12/52/52/5
Full sister excluded1/21/21/2
Paternal brother excluded1/101/101/10
Full nephew excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Mother, Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/31/31/3
Mother 1/32/92/92/9
Father's father 1/68/278/278/27
Full sister excluded4/274/274/27
Full paternal uncle excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Full cousin excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Paternal brother excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Paternal sister excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Daughter's son, Daughter's daughter

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter's son 2/32/32/31/2
Daughter's daughter 1/31/31/31/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Daughter's son, Daughter's daughter

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter's son 1/21/21/21/3
Daughter's daughter × 21/21/21/22/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Daughter's daughter, Sister's son, Maternal grandfather

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter's daughter 11/21/21/2
Sister's son excluded1/31/31/3
Maternal grandfather excluded1/61/61/6
Open in calculator

Differs for: Sister's son, Maternal grandfather

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Sister's son excluded3/53/53/5
Maternal grandfather 12/52/52/5
Open in calculator

Differs for: Sister's son, Sister's daughter, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Sister's son 2/32/52/53/10
Sister's daughter 1/31/51/53/10
Maternal aunt excluded2/52/52/5
Open in calculator

Differs for: Maternal uncle, Maternal aunt, Paternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Maternal uncle 2/9needs a scholar's review2/91/6
Maternal aunt 1/91/91/6
Paternal aunt 2/32/32/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Wife, Daughter's daughter

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Wife 1/4needs a scholar's review1/41/4
Daughter's daughter 3/43/43/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/2needs a scholar's review1/21/2
Maternal aunt 1/21/21/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Wife, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Wife 1/4needs a scholar's review1/41/4
Maternal aunt 3/43/43/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Daughter's daughter, Maternal grandfather

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter's daughter 13/43/43/4
Maternal grandfather excluded1/41/41/4
Open in calculator

Differs for: Daughter's son, Sister's son

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Daughter's son 11/21/21/2
Sister's son excluded1/21/21/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Sister's son, Paternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Sister's son 1needs a scholar's reviewexcludedexcluded
Paternal aunt excluded11
Open in calculator

Differs for: Sister's son, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Sister's son 13/53/53/5
Maternal aunt excluded2/52/52/5
Open in calculator

Differs for: Maternal grandfather, Maternal uncle

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Maternal grandfather 1needs a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's review1
Maternal uncle excludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Daughter's daughter, Maternal grandfather

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/2needs a scholar's review1/21/2
Daughter's daughter 1/23/83/8
Maternal grandfather excluded1/81/8
Open in calculator

Differs for: Sister's son, Sister's daughter

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Sister's son 2/32/32/31/2
Sister's daughter 1/31/31/31/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Maternal grandfather, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Maternal grandfather 1needs a scholar's reviewneeds a scholar's review1
Maternal aunt excludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Maternal uncle, Maternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Maternal uncle 2/32/32/31/2
Maternal aunt 1/31/31/31/2
Open in calculator

Differs for: Maternal uncle, Paternal aunt

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Maternal uncle 1/3needs a scholar's review1/31/3
Paternal aunt 2/32/32/3
Open in calculator

Differs for: Father's father, Full brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Father's father 11/21/21/2
Full brother excluded1/21/21/2
Maternal uncle excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Husband, Mother, Father's father, Full sister

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/31/31/3
Mother 1/32/92/92/9
Father's father 1/68/278/278/27
Full sister excluded4/274/274/27
Daughter's son excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Differs for: Full brother, Maternal brother

HeirḤanafīMālikīShāfiʿīḤanbalī
Husband 1/21/21/21/2
Mother 1/61/61/61/6
Full brother excluded1/91/9excluded
Maternal brother × 21/32/92/91/3
Daughter's daughter excludedexcludedexcludedexcluded
Open in calculator

Related